// weapon comparison
Mushroom Spear vs Obsidian Swordfish
Melee weapons · post-golem tier
Mushroom Spear
Melee
DPS with crit: 93.6
DPS without crit: 90.0
Obsidian Swordfish
Melee
winner · higher DPS
DPS with crit: 252
DPS without crit: 210
Stat-by-stat
computed| Stat | Mushroom Spear | Obsidian Swordfish |
|---|---|---|
| Damage | 60 | 70 |
| Use time | 40 ticks | 20 ticks |
| Crit chance | 4% | 20% |
| Knockback | 6.2 | 6.5 |
| Defense | 0 | 0 |
| Mana cost | 0 | 0 |
| Shoot speed | 5.5 | 4 |
| Sells for | — | 20 |
When to use which
open DPS calculator →Pick Mushroom Spear if…
Pick Obsidian Swordfish if…
- You want higher raw damage per hit (70 vs 60).
- You prefer faster use time (20 ticks vs 40).
- You're stacking crit-chance gear (+16% over Mushroom Spear).
- Pure DPS matters most — Obsidian Swordfish wins by 158 DPS.
Frequently asked
Which deals more DPS: Mushroom Spear or Obsidian Swordfish? +
Mushroom Spear averages 93.6 DPS with crit. Obsidian Swordfish averages 252.0 DPS with crit. Obsidian Swordfish is ahead by 158.4 DPS.
Are Mushroom Spear and Obsidian Swordfish from the same progression tier? +
Yes — both belong to the post-golem tier.